Day 12 – A book you used to love but don’t anymoreThere are surely dozens, if not hundreds of books in this category, including most of the ones I read as a child, and especially as a small child. Were I to re-encounter
Cookie Monster and the Cookie Tree, I might find it charming, but I doubt I would feel the same
love for it that I did as a three-year-old.
However, I think I can answer this most honestly by naming the series that falls most emphatically on both sides of that question -- used to love, don't anymore -- god this is embarrassing --
The Baby-Sitters Club by Ann M. Martin. I was first given a few of these at the age of six, by the daughter of a family friend who would've been around 11 or 12 at the time, and was thus a Cool Older Girl whose tastes I sought to emulate. The books themselves were also about Cool Older Girls, who did grown-up things like babysit for other children and have weird emotional disagreements that I didn't understand at all. I was addicted immediately. For the next few years I read all of them I could get my hands on, working my way quickly through the stacks inherited from the aforementioned family friend, then plundering our local library for the rest of the series. God help me, I even read some of the
Baby-Sitters' Little Sister spin-off series, although with a protagonist who was both my own age and an insufferable prat, they failed to hold my interest.
I read a whole bunch of other trash over the same period (
The Saddle Club,
Sweet Valley [whatevers], &c.), but my mother seemed to have developed a particular distaste for the
Baby-Sitters. I don't know why she picked on them more than the others -- perhaps she sampled one -- but in any case, by the time I was eight she was trying desperately to distract me from them, telling me how awfully badly they were written, trying to get me to read something else, something
better for my developing little mind. Which a) seemed a bit unnecessary, since at the same time I was reading all that trash I was
also reading every animal book I could get my hands on, as well as various potted children's histories and sanitized biographies of major historical figures, and all sorts of other 'educational' type books (and, yes, even the occasional book from the high canon of children's literature); and b) only served to make me all the more aggressively voracious in reading them. At one point she even drew up a bargain with me whereby I had to read one 'good' book in between each
Baby-Sitters book. The deal lasted for all of one book, and totally ruined
Sounder for me, since rather than enjoying the story as I might have, I was only dragging myself through it so I could get back to my teen-adulation crack-pipe.
Fortunately, by the time I'd reached the age of the characters themselves, I'd gotten myself a bit of taste, and started seeing the books for the utter garbage they are. I'll never get those hours back, nor clear out the mind-clutter currently and inexorably occupied by the doings of insipid characters I now care little about (tucked away in the same overspilling mental files as 'all the lyrics to involuntarily-memorized pop songs' and 'overheard celebrity factoids'), but I've made a sort of peace with that. What still bothers me a bit, though, is that all of my peers'
other childhood vices, with which I had little engagement, seem to have developed a sort of pop-nostalgic caché. Mario, Batman, Pokemon, etc. I played the last a little, but for the rest I've had to learn all the references from the wrong end -- much like how, having been raised on 'The Simpsons', I tend to 'get' a lot of the references therein only years later, when I finally get around to seeing this or that Classic Film. When questioned I usually tell people, as un-haughtily as I can, that I spent my childhood out in the woods catching lizards and playing with actual rather than virtual turtles (which is
also true), and carefully neglect to mention
The Baby-Sitters Club.
( Upcoming Days )